 
 
  ©  2014-2021 Copyright by P. K. H. Groth, Denver, Colorado, USA  All rights reserved -  See contact page for for permission to republish article 
  excerpts.
 
 
 
  Declining Colorado Elk Herds
 
 
  Colorado
  Elk
  Herds
  Declining:
  
  To
  etter
  understand
  the
  reasons
  for
  waning
  elk
  herds,
  let
  talk
  about 
  emerging
  research
  into
  how
  bird
  reproduction
  rates
  affected
  by
  human
  intrusion.
  I
  believe
  elk
  herds
  are 
  dealing because of unrelenting noise and expanding development of many types
  Colorado
  has
  a
  vibrant
  petroleum
  extraction
  industry.
  The
  horizontal
  drilling
  for
  and
  extraction
  of
  oil 
  and
  gas
  has
  often
  overwhelmed
  government
  regulators.
  Some
  researchers
  are
  trying
  to
  keep
  up
  with 
  how
  oil
  exploration
  affects
  wildlife.
  University
  of
  Colorado
  scientist
  Nathan
  Kleist
  conducted
  a
  2010-
  2014
  study
  of
  the
  effects
  of
  oil
  exploitation
  noise
  influencing
  the
  health
  of
  two
  species
  of
  birds
  -
  the 
  western
  and
  mountain
  bluebird
  and
  the
  ash-throated
  flycatcher.
  They
  analyzed
  the
  hatchling
  success, 
  nestling
  body
  size,
  and
  feather
  length
  (a
  proxy
  for
  normal
  body
  health/growth).
  Blood
  sample
  analyses 
  disclosed
  the
  birds
  had
  lower
  levels
  of
  the
  key
  stress
  hormone
  corticosterone
  in
  areas
  where
  noise
  was 
  historically
  unusually
  elevated.
  “You
  might
  think
  this
  means
  they
  [birds}
  are
  not
  stressed,”
  said
  coauthor 
  Christopher
  Lowrey,
  a
  stress
  physiologist
  at
  CU’s
  Denver
  Department
  of
  Integrative
  Physiology.
  “But 
  when
  organisms
  are
  under
  chronic
  stress
  that
  is
  inescapable
  for
  long
  periods
  of
  time,
  the
  organisms 
  adapt
  to
  dial
  down
  the
  stress
  response
  systems.
  You
  might
  think
  of
  this
  as
  making
  the
  best
  out
  of
  a
  sad 
  situation, but there are negative outcomes associated with this.”
  Humans
  also
  have
  negative,
  long-term
  effects
  of
  unusual
  stress.
  Post-Traumatic
  Stress
  Syndrome,
  Post-
  Partum
  stress
  of
  mothers,
  chronic
  fatigue
  syndrome,
  fibromyalgia
  and
  hypothyroidism
  are
  human 
  responses
  to
  unrelenting
  stress(es).
  Epigenetic
  frontier
  researchers
  disclose
  these
  stress
  reactions
  can 
  be
  biogenetically
  encoded
  to
  affect
  problems
  in
  future
  generations.
  [See
  deer
  avoid
  nonexistent
  fences 
  link].
  Let’s
  look
  at
  the
  observation’s
  of
  bluebird
  and
  flycatchers.
  Nathan
  Kleist
  and
  other
  researchers
  noticed 
  historically
  abnormal
  oil
  and
  gas
  drilling
  noise
  affected
  the
  health
  of
  hatchlings.
  Their
  feather
  growth 
  was
  reduced,
  as
  was
  their
  body
  size.
  Offspring
  were
  less
  equipped
  to
  survive.
  A
  study
  conclusion
  was 
  that
  regions
  of
  loudest
  machinery
  noise
  was
  birds
  could
  not
  hear
  predator
  sounds
  as
  well,
  and
  survival 
  declined.
  Parenting
  birds
  were
  overpowered
  in
  communicating,
  and
  this
  resulted
  in
  reduced
  parental 
  efficacy
  for
  raising
  young;
  more
  young
  died.
  Lowrey
  said,
  “It
  is
  easy
  to
  kind
  of
  accept
  human-made
  noise 
  is
  just
  a
  part
  of
  our
  modern
  environment,
  and
  that’s
  just
  the
  way
  it
  is.
  But
  is
  that
  desirable?
  This
  study 
  would suggest it is not.” Hernandez – Denver Post – January 13, 2018
  Eagle
  Valley
  Elk
  Herd
  Declines
  50%
  -
  Or
  More:
  
  In
  ten
  years,
  the
  number
  of
  elk
  in
  Colorado’s
  prime
  elk 
  area
  declined
  to
  half
  from
  Vail
  to
  Glenwood
  Springs
  –
  a
  short
  time
  for
  such
  a
  catastrophic
  change. 
  CPW’s
  Craig
  Westcoat
  said
  “We
  are
  not
  seeing
  the
  animals
  migrate
  to
  another
  area
  or
  permanently 
  move
  somewhere
  else.
  They
  are
  just
  dead
  and
  gone.”
  Aerial
  surveys
  and
  computer
  modeling
  disclosed 
  the
  2002
  resident
  elk
  population
  of
  10,600
  declined
  in
  only
  fourteen
  years
  to
  6,554
  in
  2016.
  The 
  ominous
  data
  showed
  that
  the
  elk
  calving
  decreased
  from
  50/100
  to
  30/100
  cows.
  The
  threshhold
  for
  a 
  stable
  herd
  is
  34
  to
  35
  calves
  per
  100
  cows.
  CPW’s
  wildlife
  manager
  Bill
  Andree
  said,
  “There
  is
  no
  one 
  individual
  reason
  for
  this
  population
  decline.”
  While
  there
  was
  drought
  and
  predator
  pressure,
  the 
  biggest
  contributor
  was
  disruptive
  intrusion
  of
  recreationists.
  It
  is
  increasingly
  difficult
  for
  animals
  to 
  find respite from humans. D. Post, Kyle 19, 2018 p7a
  Flat
  Tops
  Habitat
  Loss
  :
  I
  predicted
  in
  my
  2013
  book
  that
  motorized
  recreationists
  were
  overloading
  the 
  southern
  Flat
  Tops
  north
  of
  the
  Eagle
  Valley.
  It
  is
  becoming
  increasingly
  difficult
  for
  animals
  to
  find 
  sanctuary
  from
  human
  intrusion
  throughout
  the
  year.
  This
  writer
  has
  witnessed
  the
  southern
  Flat
  Tops 
  being
  inundated
  by
  after
  work
  and
  weekend
  joy
  riders
  exploring
  4WD
  enthusiasts,
  and
  roving
  ATV 
  advocates
  probing
  the
  more
  remote
  areas.
  This
  is
  occurring
  because
  of
  the
  Eagle-Gypsum-Glenwood 
  Springs very rapid, rocketing home and business  development occured during the past decade.
  The
  constant
  travel
  of
  ATVs,
  dune
  buggies,
  dirt
  bikes
  and
  “souped
  up”
  trucks
  create
  an
  intrusive
  noise 
  far
  away
  from
  roads.
  The
  bourgeoning
  towns
  of
  Eagle
  and
  Gypsum
  have
  also
  experienced
  a
  cultural 
  change.
  Many
  recent
  residents
  regard
  loud
  mufflered
  vehicles
  as
  a
  sign
  of
  prestige,
  while
  others
  use
  (of 
  necessity?)
  poorly
  maintained
  noisy
  rattling
  vehicles.
  The
  stylish
  gnarly
  tires
  used
  on
  gravel
  roads
  emit
  a 
  low
  frequency,
  far-traveling
  sounds.
  
  Add
  to
  this
  the
  current
  rage
  to
  go
  sport
  shooting
  with
  guns, 
  especially
  high
  capacity
  ones,
  and
  you
  recognize
  the
  recipe
  for
  extreme
  animal
  stress
  with
  its 
  consequences. There is no place of real quiet if you stop and listen.
  Humans
  can
  hear
  SOME
  of
  the
  din
  that
  continues
  from
  dawn
  to
  well
  into
  the
  night.
  However,
  humans 
  cannot
  hear
  the
  higher
  and
  lower
  frequencies
  heard
  by
  animals.
  Particularly,
  the
  midrange
  frequencies 
  are
  acoustically
  absorbed
  by
  the
  air,
  vegetation
  and
  topography.
  Very
  low
  frequencies
  travel
  much 
  farther
  because
  they
  travel
  not
  through
  the
  air,
  but
  over
  the
  ground
  surface.
  
  These
  long-traveling 
  background infrasounds are a constant irritation to animals. [see our web page on infrasounds].
  So,
  it
  is
  no
  wonder
  to
  me
  that
  the
  elk
  herds
  are
  diminishing.
  The
  elk
  will
  eventually
  only
  be
  able
  to 
  propagate
  in
  remote
  valleys
  and
  inaccessible
  wilderness
  areas.
  These
  too
  are
  under
  assault
  by 
  recreationists who want to allow bicycling, hang gliding, drones, and aircraft/ballon aerial tourism. 
  I
  do
  agree
  with
  some
  wildlife
  biologists
  that
  there
  is
  an
  increase
  in
  lion
  and
  bear
  populations
  which 
  result
  in
  elk
  casualties.
  
  
  My
  observation
  is
  that
  lions
  have
  moved
  into
  higher
  altitudes
  as
  the
  climate 
  warms.
  Bears
  seem
  to
  be
  restricted
  more
  because
  their
  mast
  food
  supply
  is
  still
  pinned
  to
  lower
  wetter 
  altitudes.
  
  However,
  bears
  emerging
  from
  hibernation
  are
  villians
  at
  killing
  young
  elk
  calves.
  
  
  D.
  Post 
  June 19-2018